[x]
All Deviations
All Deviations
[x]

A Spectacular Failure

Journal Entry: Sun Apr 6, 2008, 2:30 PM
I was talking with a friend at work this week about the many crippling events we experienced during our lovely years in public education. And we were talking about what *should* have happened, how things could be better. He's not an artist, but we both saw that the saddest thing our education beat into us was a fear of failure. We learned conformity, of course, and that was a pretty terrible lesson, but more than that, we learned to play it safe, to only do what we knew we could do well. Because you are punished when you fail, ridiculed in front of the class, graded poorly. And don't you think it would be so much better if the reverse were true? If you were rewarded for taking risks? If the point were to explain what you were trying to accomplish and where it went wrong; to prove that you learned something rather than just produced something?

Once when I was in eighth grade my science teacher asked us to build an apple corer. Most of the students went for the straight-forward dropped-weight approach. Me? I designed a Rube Goldberg contraption with a marble and the whole shebang. The rickety thing fell apart before it even started, of course, because I have no engineering skills whatsoever. But my teacher looked at the design drawing and laughed so hard that she gave me a good grade anyway. It was the first time in my life that had ever happened. That someone rewarded me for ambition instead of achievement.

I wish I could remember that more often in my present life. Because I do fail on a pretty damn ambitious scale - I can't just make a tiny mistake like normal people, I have to completely destroy huge expensive canvases and shred brushes to useless snarls and waste pots and pots of paints. And I always feel like such a monumental failure afterwards that I want to crawl into a hole and never paint again. But I'm trying to tell myself that all those voices are wrong, that it's better I be a really spectacular failure than a perfectly ordinary success. And next week, goddamnit, I'm gonna buy some more paper and try again.

  • Mood: Defeated
  • Listening to: Michael Penn: Walter Reed

Devious Comments

love 0 0 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0

~gapriest:icongapriest: Apr 6, 2008, 6:22:33 PM
I read something in Psychology Today to this effect--about perfectionism and how we're taught to fear failure, thus stifling creativity, etc... You're right, and I go through the same stuff. Fortunately, I'm an optimist so I keep climbing back up... but I chose the handle 'Marsyas' in forums for a reason. ;P
~Haramaratharagon:iconHaramaratharagon: Apr 6, 2008, 7:13:37 PM
Hmmm... Thanks for sharing!

I'm currently getting my teaching credential, and I think that encouragement and support for people who try, regardless of outcome can be a great thing... although I suppose not for every subject... like math or something... but certainly something that needs to be considered.

Encouraging and pushing children to think (dumb cliche) outside the box is something that really can boost a child's sense of self worth and value.

Thanks for sharing and the reminder.

LM
~mleiv:iconmleiv: Apr 6, 2008, 8:27:47 PM
I don't know that I'd recommend simply rewarding children for effort. That kind of "everyone's special" approach tends to discourage students from competitive achievement, which is #1) a big ego boost for kids who otherwise likely have very little to be proud of (think: nerds) and #2) a great way to motivate kids to work hard in class.

I think what I'm suggesting is encouraging students who are already doing well in class to be *more* competitive, to try to "beat" the other students by attempting more - even if in that attempt they end up failing. But then their failure demonstrates a greater grasp of the concept and creativity than simply accomplishing the "status quo."

When I was in math, I took particular pleasure solving all my proofs in reverse. It made me laugh and made boring school a little more fun. :)
~mleiv:iconmleiv: Apr 6, 2008, 8:41:08 PM
Reading Psychology Today? /impressed I just finished Predictably Irrational, but I think that's about the limit of my understanding, LOL. Fascinated, mind you, but I have to be talked down to. :)

Marsyas - ah, beloved obscure Greek Mythology (also reading Restless Dead right now... a little *above* the limit of my understanding, alas). Sounds like he's not entirely the optomist, though. More like overconfident, but I've often considered that a flaw the rest of us could use a little more of. (The Greeks, on the other hand, were more obsessed with conformity and social stability.)
~gapriest:icongapriest: Apr 6, 2008, 10:32:35 PM
I just read articles from it every now and then at the library. ;P Anything to help my addled brain. I do love reading psychology and about mythology though, especially Carl Jung and Joseph Campbell's stuff.

I think Marsyas reminds me of how I thought as a kid--that I could do anything. Of course, I realize my limits now, but his myth reminds me that I have to be willing to be 'flayed alive' (as I often am) if I want to attempt anything.

And... hey, by some accounts he actually performed better in the competition. ;P
~Haramaratharagon:iconHaramaratharagon: Apr 7, 2008, 1:11:00 PM
Hmm, that's a good point.

I know that in a classroom environment where we have a lot of kids with different learning levels, that we need to give motivation to the kids who are ahead of others. Challenging them could help develop their creative thinking, while the other students are catching up.

God, knows I've learned a lot from my failures, creative or not, I had to drop of college twice before going back and getting my degree. =P
~MatrixRunner57:iconMatrixRunner57: Apr 11, 2008, 9:04:53 AM
Hi Mleiv,

I decided to leave a message here, too. In addition to the email. I visited your celestial store on Cafepress and I was wondering if you could release a men's shirt featuring the forbidden fruit logo. Currently, it is only on two women's shirts. Have a great day!
~mleiv:iconmleiv: Apr 12, 2008, 11:06:13 AM
Well, good luck! You know, it's like parenting: you can do a fabulous job 99% of the time and that one screw-up is gonna be the traumatic event some kid's shrink has to hear about for the next 50 years, LOL. I wouldn't do it myself, but I admit that I had some teachers who really made my life worth living (not in Art, mind you, but tucked in there somewhere).
~mleiv:iconmleiv: Apr 12, 2008, 11:09:02 AM
Done. Those images are all CC byncsa (noncommercial shared), so you can technically make your own shirts (...since cafepress limits what I can offer to one image per product style). I will work on getting the url in question back up and the images correctly stamped for use in future shirts - just too much else to work on right now.